• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Andrea J. Johnson - Craft Killer Fiction - ajthenovelist

Killer Courthouse Cozies Guaranteed to Renew Your Faith in Justice

  • HOME
  • Andrea J. Johnson
  • Books
  • Blog
  • Sign Up
  • Contact

Blog

My Books Are More Than “Black Fiction”

I recently had a self-described “white” fan contact me through this website to tell me how much they enjoyed my book and to ask me why the book was labeled “Black Fiction” by her local librarian. The idea confused me as well because although I am a Black author who enjoys the benefits of being included on must-read lists that support POC writers, my first instinct wouldn’t be to label my books “Black Fiction.” Why? Well, the phrase doesn’t indicate anything about the books’ content. Yes, I am Black, and my novels contain Black characters, but the book isn’t meant just for Black people any more than science fiction is solely meant for white cisgender men.

To put it mildly, I was upset and unsure how to respond to my new fan. I wanted to be encouraging, but I needed to let her (and her librarian) know that by putting my book in that singular box my novels fail to reach the intended audience–> COZY MYSTERY LOVERS of all shapes, sizes, and colors.

If you want to read my full fan response, keep scrolling and leave me a comment with your thoughts. I probably shouldn’t have said anything. Besides, I am sure it is difficult for you, dear reader, to tell if my reaction is appropriate without having read the initial letter, but I made a conscious decision to keep the fan’s name private.

Dear Fan, thank you for reaching out. I am honored that you thought well enough of my book to share your experience and that you’ve added the series to your list of authors to watch.

While I am heartbroken to hear that libraries are still labeling fiction by author ethnicity rather than genre—especially after all this country has been through over the past nine months—the practice (unfortunately) is not new. Considering you’re on my side in this, I doubt you wrote me to hear a rant…but I can’t help myself.

First, let me confirm that your instincts about the egregiousness of this practice are correct and that I appreciate your efforts to question the premise (as it is one that authors of color have been railing against for decades). 

Even though the librarian is correct in stating that I don’t get a say in such distinctions once the book reaches its distribution hub, she or he is incorrect when stating that readers of color enter libraries looking for those ethnic labels and that such stickers are “necessary.” I assure you we do not and they are not.

By rattling off that tiresome adage, the librarian is perpetuating the stereotype that people of color are some ignorant breed of (non)reader who can’t make distinctions for themselves and thus must be cattle-prodded into a specific direction and that POCs never read anything written by people outside their culture—a doubly ridiculous statement when we note how few new Black authors there are in the current marketplace and how small a POC’s reading pool would be if the librarian’s assumptions were true. 

The label “Black Fiction” is especially disheartening since this distinction doesn’t actually reflect content (i.e. the moniker doesn’t have a clear-cut definition) but is rather a catchall for books with a POC on the cover or those with a POC author. Sadly, this bias cuts into the potential readership for the work and my overall revenue. To put it plainly, I wrote Poetic Justice for the masses. The story reflects Americana right down to its fictional location. However, that dubious label means my work is only being marketed to 13 percent of the population, so I get put on the shelf beside a hodge-podge of unrelated books when I should be next to Kate Carlisle, Joanna Fluke, and Vicki Delany, who all share my readership and could help widen my fanbase. 

As you so aptly stated, many White readers have been mislead to believe “Black Fiction” is code for some secret content to that excludes them. Even if that were the case (which I can’t stress enough it isn’t), how is anybody ever going to learn about their neighbors’ struggles? We should encourage everyone to discover these stories–that’s how societies grow into a unified collective. I could send your librarian dozens of high-profile articles listing the detriment of this practice. Hint. Hint. But at the end of the day, I have to presume the librarian meant well and that as the popularity of my series grows, so will my chance of emerging from purgatory.

If you read this far, THANKS! I appreciate you seeking out the book and bringing this to my attention. The sequel, Deceptive Justice, releases November 9, 2021. My website and Goodreads page include a description if you’re interested. Join my mailing list for a reminder of the new release. In the meantime, stay cozy!

Let me end by encapsulating this rant with a quote from Michelle Obama’s Netflix Documentary, Becoming: “If we can open up a little bit more to each other and share our stories, our real stories, that’s what breaks down barriers.” This statement is exactly why I don’t simply want to be labeled “Black Fiction.” How can I possibly reach one and teach one if I’m only preaching to the choir?

Release Date for Deceptive Justice

Great news! We have a release date for Deceptive Justice, the second book in the Victoria Justice Mysteries—April 5, 2022. Fans will be able to pick up the book in paperback and eBook at Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Bookshop, Apple Books, GooglePlay, Kobo, Walmart and Target online, and anywhere else books or sold. I plan to have a cover reveal within the next sixty days. In the meantime, here is a sample of what’s on the horizon for our next installment:

When Victoria Justice finds herself on the phone with a mad bomber, she doesn’t think twice about springing into action to diffuse the situation. After all, the Bickerton Superior Courthouse is no stranger to all manner of crimes. However, a mysterious package found in the lobby a few minutes later leads to a building evacuation that has everyone pointing fingers, that is, until a car explodes in the parking lot killing a government official. Authorities search the area for clues and determine a recently vindicated arsonist is to blame, but the arrest sparks an alternate theory for Victoria who believes the real culprit is still at large and that she may have been the true target.

With no leads but a manuscript of the initial bomb threat and a faint audio recording of the caller’s scrambled voice, Victoria recruits former State Trooper Ashton North and local newsman Mike Slocum to help her weather the firestorm of community outrage. But can the two men refrain from killing each other long enough to keep Victoria alive and capture the murderer?

Fans of Knives Out, Law & Order, and Murder, She Wrote will love these killer courtroom cozies with their unexpected twists and turns. Order the first book in the series today, and look for Deceptive Justice in stores this fall.

PREORDER DECEPTIVE JUSTICE HERE!

Productivity is the Key to Success!

It’s never too late to change your life. Have a book you want to write? A website you want to build? A business you need to start? The Heart Breathings Productivity Bootcamp (HB90) is exactly what you need to become more powerful and more focused than ever before. READ MY FULL REVIEW HERE!

The creator of this phenomenal course, Sarra Cannon, is a YouTube entrepreneur and seven-figure indie author best known for her Shadow Demons Saga. In one week, Sarra will walk you through how to find time and energy to tackle the goals that mean the most to you as well as how to hone those goals so that you can reach your idea life.

As a writer who often found herself working hard but never quite finishing everything, I found this class invaluable for fighting overwhelm and frustration because Sarra’s approach to organizational planning breaks things down into bite-sized chunks that make the impossible seem easy.

If you’d like to learn more about this course, please contact me through this site or simply go directly to the HB90 Bootcamp Homepage. Every member who signs up for the seven-day course receives a free quarterly planner from Sarra and lifetime access to the lessons. Enrollment is opens June 4. Apply today!

Agatha Nominations – Best First Mystery

Spring is in the air and that means the annual Agatha Awards are just around the corner. Poetic Justice is eligible for nomination under the Best First Mystery category and ballots were recently sent out to those planning to attend the awards ceremony held by Malice Domestic, July 14-17, 2021. I would encourage anyone who has received a submission form for this year’s awards to nominate my book for its unique heroine, a court stenographer turned amateur sleuth, and the underlying message it conveys about being underestimated by your gender or race.

Even if you are not eligible to vote, consider attending the event! As previously mentioned, the honors are hosted by Malice Domestic, a fan convention established in 1989 to celebrate the traditional and cozy mysteries best mirroring the works of Agatha Christie.* Hence, the name of the award, and the prestige bestowed upon any novel who receives the distinction.

Eligible books must have a murder-based whodunit at its core with no explicit sex, gore, or violence. The other awards given during the ceremony include Best Novel, Best Historical Novel, Best Short Story, Best Non-Fiction, and Best Children’s/Young Adult Mystery. Visit this great blog post by Gabriel Valjan to see all of the books eligible for nomination.

Remember, the event is open to anyone who wants to attend, and registration can be found HERE. I hope to see you there!

Photo Courtesy of MaliceDomestic.org

*Agatha Christie was an English writer who amassed sixty-six detective novels and fourteen short story collections in her lifetime. She is best known for creating fictional detectives Hercule Poirot and Miss Marple, but she also wrote the world’s longest-running play, The Mousetrap (1952 to 2020). Guinness World Records names Christie the best-selling fiction writer of all time since her novels have sold over two billion copies.

Want Great Reviews? Follow me on Goodreads!

I love reading books as much as I love writing them. My passion for literature is so voracious that I try to read at least one book each week. So if you’re looking to catch my picks in the mystery, thriller, romance, and self-help genres (my favorite categories), I encourage you to follow me on Goodreads where I post my thoughts on every book I purchase as well as recommend my favorites to everyone in my circle.

Here are two of the reviews I posted this week. You can also find some of them on my Twitter feed if you’re not yet a Goodreads member.

Until next time, grab a night light and keep reading!

A Review of Janelle Brown’s Pretty Things

BEWARE. If you’re expecting this year’s Girl on a Train or Something in the Water, you’re going to be sorely disappointed. Don’t get me wrong, this book is excellent for what it is on its own merits, but it has been marketed incorrectly. I was given a copy by a friend who thought it was a heist thriller turned psychological suspense, which it is for the first 50 pages or so. But overall, this book blends the poetic language of literary fiction with the “finding yourself” conceit often found in women’s fiction. So trust the reviews that note this is a character study where two women attempt to course correct their lives under the deeply rooted (and highly convoluted) set of circumstances created by their intertwined family histories.

But even with that knowledge, the pacing felt too introspective for me. There were whole chapters with no dialogue where we’re told what happens rather than shown. Each woman explains her side of the story, so the insertion of multi-tiered flashbacks often stifle the narrative flow at points where the story should blast off. Plus, many of the plot points seem to hinge on a series of odd coincidences (e.g. someone talks about the combo to their family safe in the middle of a crowded coffee shop) and unlikelihoods (e.g. an old blackmail letter still hangs around 12 years later or the dairy of someone not known to have one is found). And yet, the point of view the writer gives our heroines is so visceral that in most instances the plot-based faux paus, exposition, and clunky clues pay off in the end.

Even still, it doesn’t add up to an ending that is as gasp worthy as the book expects. Instead, it simply feels as if the author is more concerned with giving us a shocking twist than creating a conclusion that feels authentic. Not to mention, the final chapters are the one place where it might have been interesting to hear how the characters felt about what was done, but we get nothing except a surprisingly tidy Hollywood ending.

Would I recommend the book? Absolutely! The writing is excellent, and the lesson learned is noteworthy: Take responsibility for your own actions. Don’t let other people define who you are or what you become. Or to steal a line from The Terminator, “We have no fate but what we make.” BUT even with a four-star review, my warning remains: Those looking for a thrilling read are better off picking up The Sun Down Motel by Simone St. James (see review below).

A Review of Simone St. James’s The Sundown Motel

Who says you can’t judge a book by its cover? In fact, the only reason I picked up The Sun Down Motel was because the front page art looked oddly similar to the movie poster for the brilliantly twisty Bad Times at the El Royale starring Jeff Bridges, Chris Hemsworth, and the phenomenal Cynthia Erivo. (That’s yet another story I picked up without prior knowledge, but I digress). Of course, the similarities between the movie poster and book cover were probably intentional on the part of the publisher as both works are thrillers, but I am relieved to report that like its cinematic cousin, The Sun Down Motel is a deliciously eerie haunt that I’d gladly revisit again and again.

Don’t get me wrong, The Sun Down Motel and Bad Times at the El Royale have no similarities except that they both center on some shady sh*t going down at dangerously dated hotels. I only brought up the film to say that if you liked one you might like the other. But to be clear, The Sun Down Motel is a paranormal thriller, which may be off-putting to some—I’ll admit if I’d known spooks and specters played a role, I may not have read the book. However, the ghostly elements are handled in a manner that feels real (i.e. played more for gravitas and historical significance than horror) and thus gives the novel’s otherwise straightforward plot some much needed heart.

The main tale centers on Carly, a young college co-ed who has recently lost her mother to cancer, so she goes on a quest to explore her family tree by digging into the disappearance of her mother’s sister. The trip down memory lane takes Carly to Fell, New York, where she inadvertently adopts the same life her aunt had back in 1982—the audience knows this tidbit because the book alternates chapters between Carly and her Aunt Vivian. Of course, multiple POV is a well-worn literary technique at this point, but I have to admit this is where the novel shows its brilliance since the author seamless intertwines the two women’s adventures so that we feel as if we’re reading about one person with extremely high stakes. There’s even a hidden women empowerment message embedded within, so if you don’t like ghosts or scary stories, this is still well worth the read. The novel strikes the perfect balance between mystery, mischief, and morality with a conclusion that’s surprisingly heartwarming considering the demands put on modern thrillers to have some gruesome twist ending.

Five stars. I recommend you grab your blanket and a cup of cocoa because this is the type of book enjoyed by firelight (or nightlight).

Winter Media Roundup

The second book in the Victoria Justice Mysteries is officially heading down the long pipeline to publication, so I am happy this winter brought more opportunities to share new information about my main character and how I see her developing over the course of the series.

Remember, if you’d like first crack at all of the latest dish about me and my books, follow me on Instagram or Twitter, leave a review on Goodreads, check out what I’m reading and writing on Pinterest, sign-up for my newsletter, and order my latest release via Bookshop or Amazon.

In early December, I had a wonderful opportunity to give an extensive interview to Zeringue Marshal of Campaign for the American Reader, a blog dedicated to helping patrons read more books. The Q&A covers the hidden meaning behind my books’ titles, my connection to the main character, the inspiration behind my cozy thriller series, and so much more. You can read the entire interview HERE. Let us know what you think!

Zeringue also asked me to participate in the “The Page 69 Test,” where I analyze the scene from that particular page to see if readers can successfully gather the book’s essence and main conflict (i.e. assess whether the story is good based on a single moment). Canadian philosopher Marshall McLuhan believed that any reader who turns to the sixty-ninth page and loves what they find will be happy with the book as a whole. I certainly hope that’s true with you. You’ll find the excerpt from my book and the analysis HERE.

That’s all for now, lovers of literature. Visit me next quarter when I’ll have more information about my adventures and publications.

Until then, grab a night light and keep reading!

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Page 6
  • Page 7
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 9
  • Go to Next Page »

Footer

LATEST FROM MY BLOG

HB90 Bootcamp

HB90 Bootcamp: Is It Worth $200?

Surrey International Conference Speaker Appearance 2025 - Andrea Johnson

Upcoming Speaking Event – Fall 2025

Publish and Thrive

Review: Sarra Cannon’s Self-Publishing Course – Publish & Thrive

Teaching and Learning Opportunities for Fall 2024

I’m Teaching at ITW’s Online Thriller School

CONNECT WITH ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

HERE’S WHAT I’M READING

Copyright Andrea J. Johnson © 2025